YOUR “Personalized” Student Loan Management Strategy

 

 

japanese-1206509_960_720

 

I have read and learned extensively on the topic of student loans, especially for someone who has wiped off all her educational debt as a PGY1. After learning all the factoids and nuances, loops and hoops, the singular solid conclusion I have arrived at is that student loan management plan is a personal choice.

I have heard some co-residents said they would stick with IBR and PSLF for now solely because they would regret forgoing PSLF before they know its not feasible (for example: after 6 years on IBR/PSLF, they can not find a 503c W2 job after completing training.)

I have also heard others say they’d rather have the peace of mind by refinancing now. Getting a fixed interest rate (lower than fed rates), freeing up some cash flow in training ($0-$100 minimum/month payment with LinkCapital, DRB), and keeping job options open instead of limiting them by forgiveness-eligibility.


calculations
For many of us, deciding what to do with our student loans seems as complicated and daunting as this mathematical mass.

 

This survey is intended to break down the complex decision matrix of student loan management. YOUR answers will guide you to what is best for you. Feel free to change the point assignments or add/subtract questions as you see fit. It is meant to get you thinking what matters to you.

Remember how you went a round of large-volume professional speed-dating during MS4 interview season before the Match? You considered as many aspects as you wished/could tolerate, and did some soul searching, then deliberated YOUR rank list.

Student loan management strategy, like many other complex and high-impact decisions in your life, is your choice. You’ve got the power.

I’m just trying to present facts and considerations. My ultimate goal is that you make a plan and you are happy with it Today. And that you are empowered to change your plan/action as you see fit down the road.

right choice
The key to tackling your student loan is deciding on A plan and start executing it today. Once you have considered the facts and options, you may choose from many “right” ways to become debt free.

The following survey will guide you through an intentionally more personalized/ specific approach to your student loan management strategy. This post was inspired by Dr. James Dahle aka White Coat Investor, specifically his very informative flow chart below on student loan management. You can check out his original article here. 

Student Loan Management image

 

Your task: add up the points assigned to your answers for the following questions. You will see what the these points mean at the end.

 

  1. How much total student loan do I have?
    1. <100k (1 point)
    2. 100-200k (2 points)
    3. 200-300k (3 points)
    4. 300+k (4 points)

  2. What interest rates do I have on my student loans?
    1. 1-2% (4 points)
    2. 5-7% (3 points)
    3. 8-11% (2 points)
    4. 11+% (1 point)

  3. What is the stage of my medical career?
    1. MS 1-3 (0 point)
    2. MS4 (0 point)
    3. Early PGY (1 point)
    4. Late PGY/Fellow (0 point)
    5. Non Profit W2 employee attending (2 points)
    6. Private practice attending (0 point)

300x250_10_143

Apply to Earnest by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


 

  1. Have I consolidated all my federal student loans? (Are they all eligible for forgiveness via either PSLF or 20-25 year payment plan.)
    1. All my student loans are consolidated and forgiveness-eligible. (3 points)
    2. I have NOT consolidated but I only have federal loans. (2 points)
    3. I have NOT consolidated & I have private loans in addition to fed loans. (1 point)

  2. Do I have any private loans not issued by the federal government and hence not forgiveness-eligible?
    1. No, all my loans are consolidated and forgiveness-eligible. (3 points)
    2. No, although I have not consolidated all my fed loans, I don’t have any private loans. (2 points)
    3. I have private loans. (1 point)

  3. How important is more cash flow to me TODAY? (for example, 200k debt, 70k pgy income, filing single in AZ: $652/month IBR payment vs. $0-100/month with LinkCapital/DRB)
    1. It’s essential for my current needs. (0 point)
    2. I’d like to max out my ROTH IRA knowing that it’s a tax efficient move in PGY years. (0 point)
    3. I will use this money to take advantage of my company 401k match. (0 point)
    4. I want to enjoy that cash now. (0 point)
    5. Not important. I’d rather pay that couple hundred more/month in student loans if it gets me greater savings on interest in the long term. (2 points)

DFD DRB

Apply to DRB by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


 

  1. How important is long term interest savings to me?
    1. #1 priority. I’ll do everything necessary to keep interests minimal. (2 points)
    2. Not as important as cash flow right now. I’d rather have more money monthly right now. (0 point)
    3. I like to balance cash flow with long term interest savings. (1 points)

  2. What will my income be as an attending physician?
    1. 100k (3 points)
    2. 200k (2 points)
    3. 300k (1 point)
    4. 400k+ (0 point)

  3. How much do I like to work for academic hospitals or VA/governmental agencies?
    1. I only want to work for academic hospitals. (3 points)
    2. I only want to work for VA. (3 points)
    3. I only want to work for one of the 2 above. (4 points)
    4. I am open to all career settings. (3 points)
    5. I want to be my own boss. (0 point)

Dec2015_300x250_b

Apply to Common Bond by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and DWM will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


 

  1. Do I like to be my own boss?
    1. Yes, I enjoy setting the pace of work. (0 point)
    2. Yes, I like the flexibility of 1099 contractor vs. a W2 employee. (0 point)
    3. No, I want a fixed salary and set of options in benefits and retirement saving defined for me. (3 points)

  2. Am I willing to limit my career options to get PSLF?
    1. Yes, plus my PGY training is long; there are more 503c than private practice jobs in my practice. (3 points)
    2. Yes, plus my PGY training is long (so fewer years in non-profit as attending is needed); there are more private practice than 503c jobs in my practice. (2 points)
    3. Yes, plus my PGY training is short (so more years in non-profit as attending is needed); there are more private practice than 503c jobs in my practice. (1 points)
    4. No, I don’t want to say no to job simply because it is not forgiveness-eligible. (0 point)

The higher your cumulative score, the better deal PSLF (public service loan forgiveness) will be for you.

The lower your cumulative score, you will do better by refinancing your loans right now (and sequentially whenever you can get a lower rate since there’s no costs involved, so no break-even points and just simple straight forward interest savings) and pay off your refinanced loan at the pace you choose.


Did the points assigned to the answers make sense to you? What would you have done differently if you made this survey? Any question about REPAYE vs. IBR vs. Refinance? Suggestion on how to improve this survey to help our colleagues?

Comment below!

DiscoverIt Lent Me $3600 on NEGATIVE 31% interest for 15 months



shopcash register

withdiscover it

 

and get cash back30 percent

What is the highest interest rate you have been charged for borrowing money? For some of us, credit card companies might have caught us with 15-30% interest at one point in our lives (hopefully one got out of such vicious debt quickly.) After wising up, we don’t fall into these exorbitant interest rate traps but nearly all of us still can’t avoid the federal government’s charging us 7% interest rate + up front loan origination fees (1-2%) on student loans.

 

On the flip side, have you ever dreamed of

borrowing money on NEGATIVE interest?

In other words, getting PAID to borrow money which you can apply wherever YOU see fit? This post will share my experience on getting 31% negative interest for my 2016 grocery bills!


A Minimalist’s Approach to MCAT: Excel in Medical College Admission Test and Beyond


 

Discover has been running lots of campaigns to gain greater share of the lucrative market of consumer lending, especially via credit cards. One of the most amazing deals Discover offered was to give 10% cash back when you use Apple Pay+ Discover credit cards to make purchases.

On top of that, Discover offers DOUBLE the cash back rewards for the first entire year if one opens a new discover card. The second set cash back credits a month after the anniversary.

I can’t miss out on such an amazing deal! 20% cash back on my purchases and 0% APR for the first 15 months on the debt balance!


300x250_10_143

Apply to Earnest by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


Interest free money provides fantastic leverage (to pay off 7% student loan, to fund 7-8% annualized return retirement accounts, even to pay down 3.375% mortgage).

This is Negative 20% interest for whatever purchase(s) I make which becomes a standing balance which I only make minimum payment monthly, until I pay the whole balance off right before the interest rate hikes (introductory APR 0% gets its ugly 15-20% APR after the first 15 months).

So how did I get negative 31% off of my $3600 purchase?

On the first Wednesday of every November, Sprouts Farmer’s Market (where I do most of my grocery shopping) offer their gift cards 90 cents on the dollar. I know I have a family to feed and sometimes co-workers too, I went ahead and bought $4000 worth of Sprouts gift cards. I never have $4000 cash in my bank because I like to put my cash to work (pay down debt or invest.)

Thanks to Discover, I could afford to buy $4000 worth of Sprouts gift cards and enjoy paying just $40/month payment until the 15 months of 0% APR is up.


DFD DRB

Apply to DRB by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


So here’s the math. I charged $3600 on my Discover it credit card and got $4000 of Sprouts gift cards for grocery. Discover gives me $360 back after the first statement cycle, then gives me another $360 back after my first anniversary as a card holder.

My total savings:

$400 discount off of Sprouts gift card

+

$720 cash back from Discover

= $1120 grand total for $3600 I borrowed

= Negative 31.1% interest for 15 months

 

All for just a minimum payment of $72/ month (generally my minimum payments are 1-2% of the total debt balance I carry on each card).


A Minimalist’s Approach To USMLE I: You Can Excel in Medical Boards and Beyond.


Since Discover literally paid me 31% interest to borrow money from them. There’s no reason why I won’t put the freed up cash flow into my retirement to earn me long term annualized 7-8% additional gain.

That’s debt leverage. If big banks can borrow at 0% interest, why shouldn’t little people like us who devoted most of life and money to get higher education get a little break?

Although the Apple pay 10% deal is currently off the table, you can still get 5% cash back in rotating categories. To couple that with the ongoing deal of double cash back on rewards accumulated during 1st anniversary of card opening. You still get rewarded 10% cash back for borrowing money from Discover!

I’ll be on the look out as well, and let you know if Apple Pay 10% cash back ever returns. There is talk of it, but rumor is rumor until it happens.


A Minimalist’s Approach to the Match: Enjoy Your Journey and Destination of the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP)


  • Have you ever borrowed negative interest money? How did you do it?
  • If you were to free up $4000 of cash flow for the next 15 months, where would you put that $4000? Investment? Student loans? Mortgage?
  • If you want to start taking advantage of the 10% cash back (still available right now), use my facebook link to apply. This way you will get an additional $50 cash bonus with your first purchase. DWM gets $50 too if you get approved!

Comment below and share you experience in leverage debt with NEGATIVE interests!

Wall Street to White Coat: Interviews with Dr. Unger Part II

Wyatt Unger, M.D., M.B.A, is a 3rd year radiology resident at the University of Arizona.  Wyatt earned a B.A in Economics from Northwestern University and an M.B.A. from the University of Arizona.  Prior to pursuing a career in medicine, Wyatt has worked as an equity options market maker at the NYSE/ARCA options exchange and the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), as well as a proprietary equities trader at Great Point Capital.  Wyatt has previously held Series 7, 55, and 63 certifications.

Through this “Wall Street to White Coat” interview series, Dr. Unger will share his first hand experience from Wall Street and his extensive education/ knowledge in finances and economics with his white-coat colleagues.

(We have no financial relationship.)


  • When the stock market is volatile like it is now, what is the best investment strategy the frequency and timing of putting money in the market?

There’s no clear research that one strategy outperforms another strategy when deciding when to invest during a volatile market. Warren Buffett said “when others are greedy be fearful and when others are fearful be greedy.” There are definitely opportunities in a volatile market so it is important to remain levelheaded and look for them. The most important thing is not to panic and to have a clear set of investment objectives and goals that you continue to pursue during the market volatility.

 

  • What indicators are useful for deciding if the companies undervalued (therefore a good stock to buy and hold)?

The value of the company is determined by how much income the company can generate and also how much that income is expected to grow in the future. Stocks are generally divided between growth stocks, where price-to-earnings ratio’s can be quite high and value stocks, which would generate a stable income without much growth. It is really difficult to determine if a company is undervalued looking only at these ratios. Teams of professionals with full access to their accounting books have a difficult time making this determination.  It is generally better to assume that the market has better information than you do about the value of the stock and pursue a diversified portfolio. You can set a portion of your portfolio side for single stock investments if you have a really strong feeling about an investment but realize that single stocks are inherently more risk than index funds.


 

300x250_10_143

Apply to Earnest by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


  • Should I invest or pay down my student loans?

This really depends on the interest rate you’re paying on your student loans. The long run historical average of returns for the market is around 8% but going forward this is more likely to be in the 5 to 6% range. A lot of student debt has an interest rate of 7% however the after-tax interest payment is lower so you might expect a higher rate of return with stocks.

However you have to consider that a debt is still due if you lose your job, your health or find yourself in other unforeseen circumstances. With a long time horizon and from a perspective looking just at the rates of return investing in stocks is probably better, however paying off debt will help you deal with unforeseen circumstances.


 

DFD DRB

Apply to DRB by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


  • What books on investment do you recommend reading?

I recommend A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel, Reminiscences of a Stock Operator, and anything by Warren Buffett.

 

  • What percentage of my stock holdings do you recommend for single stocks vs. index funds:

There is a lot of research out there that investors who pick single stocks underperform the market as a whole so my short answer to this question would be 0%.  Sticking to index funds will minimize your risk, save you time, and help you sleep better at night. You can allocate a portion of your investments to single stocks as you gain more experience and if you enjoy it.  There is no magic number for how much to invest in single stocks but when doing so, diversification becomes even more important in managing your downside risk, which becomes more substantial when investing in single stocks.


 

More interviews with Wyatt will be coming shortly. Are there any question you want to ask him? Comment below!

Company Match Q&A Part II

Anyone who enjoys getting 100% instant return on their invested dollar is excited about getting a company match.

This post is the 2nd part of 3-post series to answer all your questions on maximizing your company match. While this series answers specific questions about the BUMC (Banner University Medical Center) match, the general principles apply to employer contribution to employee retirement savings.

These answers were provided by Jan White, System Coordinator for the Retirement Plans at Banner, who has been with Banner for 43 years.

growing


Question 4.

Is the 4% Banner match pre or post tax?

Pre-tax.

 

Question 5.

Is there a vesting period for the match? Do I need to be a banner employer for a minimum amount of years before the match really becomes mine?

You will be vested each pay period once you are eligible for the Banner match.

 

Question 6.

How do I maximize getting the 4% Banner match?

You will receive up 4% match on your contributions each pay period as long as you make contributions to the 401k (pre-tax).  We do not match on the Roth.  There are two reasons that contributions would stop and this is if you reach the max you can contribute to the plan or you reach the IRS allowed compensation of $265,000 whichever comes first.  And when your contributions stop so does the company match.  You are 100% vested in your money and the company match on the Banner 401k plan.

 


 

300x250_10_143

Apply to Earnest by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


 

Question 7.

Will there be HSA (Health Savings Account) option for residents?

Yes the Banner Health Savings Plan is our H.S.A. approved medical plan

 

Question 8.

What happens to my UAHN 403b plan?

The vesting schedule will continue for your funds from UAHN 403b plan for the company match.  Those funds will be rolled over from UAHN on Oct 30th after close of market into the Banner 403b and no further contributions can be made to that old plan.

 

Question 9.

Is there an option for residents/ fellows to max out their 401k ROTH at 18k and just forego the 4% pretax match? Or is it mandatory that one CAN NOT contribute to the Roth component of 401k UNTIL after putting in 4% pretax contribution first?

You must contribute 4% to the pretax 401k before you can contribute anything to the 401r (Roth, post-tax) component.  And the two are combined to reach the 18k, it is not a separate 18k to each.

 


 

DFD DRB

Apply to DRB by clicking here, you will get $300 cash bonus and WCW will get a referral fee when you sign your contract. Win-win!


 

Question 10.

How soon after I get the match from banner, may I go ahead and pay taxes on the pre-tax portion (presumably 8% of my salary) of my 401k to convert it into post-tax/Roth dollars?

I will need to get back with you on this answer, if it is even possible.

I will make sure that we schedule our Fidelity rep team to be in Tucson prior to your coming into Banner to assist with enrollment and any questions you and your colleagues may have.


Save today, Get Your Employer Match today, Double Your Workhorse in Investment today.
Save today, Get Your Employer Match today, Double Your Workhorse in Investment today.

 

  • Do you have other questions?
  • Anything else you learned about your company (BUMC or otherwise) match?

Comment below!

Wall Street to White Coat: Interview Series with Dr. Unger


Wyatt Unger, M.D., M.B.A, is a 3rd year radiology resident at the University of Arizona.  Wyatt earned a B.A in Economics from Northwestern University and an M.B.A. from the University of Arizona.  Prior to pursuing a career in medicine, Wyatt has worked as an equity options market maker at the NYSE/ARCA options exchange and the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), as well as a proprietary equities trader at Great Point Capital.  Wyatt has previously held Series 7, 55, and 63 certifications.

Through this “Wall Street to White Coat” interview series, Dr. Unger will share his first hand experience from Wall Street and his extensive education/ knowledge in finances and economics with his white-coat colleagues.

(We have no financial relationship.)


 

  1. I’ve never invested before, how and where do I start?

The best way to start investing is by doing it.   I started investing when I was 10 years old when my grandfather gave me a check for Christmas and instructed me to invest in stock. I wish I could say that that stock is worth a lot of money today but it actually went to zero which taught me a really important lesson about investing and the risks of not being diversified.

It is important to realize when you’re starting investing that it is a risk and that you don’t always make money when you’re doing it. The best thing you can do is educate yourself as much as possible and start small with the understanding that a new investor is going to make mistakes.


  1. Should I invest with pretax or post tax retirement accounts or a taxable brokerage account?

You should invest with both retirement accounts and if you have extra cash flow also in a taxable brokerage account. It makes sense to max out your retirement account every year due to the tax savings but ideally you should save more than the allowed maximum in a retirement account.

That doesn’t mean all of your savings should be invested in stocks because having all of your savings in one instrument (stocks, bonds, CD, etc.) is generally not appropriate for the average investor. It is generally appropriate to have a portion of your savings invested in stocks, bonds, real estate and cash, depending on your financial situation.


  1. What is a general rule of thumb for asset allocation?

The general rule of thumb for asset allocation would be to take 100 and subtract your age and that would be the percentage invested in stocks. The remainder should be invested in bonds or other assets. Of course this also depends on your financial goals and family situation.


  1. What is spread, load, and price-to-earnings ratio?

There are a lot of complicated terms in investing that the general investor doesn’t understand. Fortunately there are many resources to help understand these terms. Some terms you might’ve heard before may include,

Spread: this is the difference between the bid and ask prices for a stock or fund.

Load: this is the fee charged by a fund or mutual fund for management. (Upfront?)

Price to earnings ratio: there are many financial ratios used to describe a stock’s financial performance. Price-to-earnings ratio is probably the most commonly cited one. This is the ratio of a stock’s market capitalization (total market value) to its after-tax earnings.


  1. What major principles should novice investor go by?

The best principal for novice investor is to follow is diversification. What diversification means is not having too much of your savings in any given asset. Assets include stocks, bonds, real estate, and cash. The reason for this is unexpected things happen frequently in the financial markets and by having your savings amongst a number of assets you minimize your downside risk when things start to go bad or if something changes in your life situation.

It also helps you sleep better at night. An excellent book for the novice investor regarding investing in index funds and the benefits of diversification would be A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel.


  1. Which index funds do you recommend investing for retirement saving purposes?

Index funds are treated like stocks but represent a large number of underlying assets. There are literally hundreds if not thousands of index funds in the marketplace now. When selecting appropriate index fund it is important to find out its management fee which should be available in the prospectus.

A new investors should start with an index fund that is broadly representative of the market. There are funds that mimic the performance of the S&P 500 (SPY), the Dow Jones industrial average (DIA), the NASDAQ composite index (QQQ) the Russell 2000 (IWM).


  1. Where do I put my money if I’m saving for short-term expenses?

For short-term expenses where you need the money to be available, stocks are generally too risky. For example suppose you need your savings for a purpose five years from now and the market happens to be down substantially that year, you put yourself in a position where you might be forced to sell at a loss or at sub-optimal time. It is generally advisable to hold funds that will be needed in the near future in less risky investments such as investment-grade bonds, treasuries, municipal bonds, or CDs.


 

A second interview with Wyatt will be coming shortly. Are there any question you want to ask him? Comment below!